Skip to content

LIMITED TIME OFFER - BUY 1 GET 1 FOR $149

Have an iPhone?

Download our app for fast and easy scanning and checkout. No impression kit, quickest delivery and chat with a performance or medical specialist live. Download our app for fast and easy scanning and checkout. Three iPhones showing the Fits Perfect app: choosing an orthotic style, a 3D scan of the left foot, and orthotic layers Download the Fits Perfect app on the App Store
or
Continue shopping in the browser. A memory foam kit will be shipped to you, prior to manufacturing, to capture an impression of your foot. Continue on website with an impression kit (shipped to you free of charge). Fits Perfect ordering steps: 1 checkout, 2 foot impression with the foam impression kit, 3 custom orthotics delivered
Previous article
Now Reading:
Orthotics vs. Arch Supports: What's the Difference?
Next article

Orthotics vs. Arch Supports: What's the Difference?

Walk down the foot care aisle or search online and you'll see arch supports, insoles, inserts, prefabricated orthotics, and custom orthotics, often used as if they mean the same thing. They don't. Each one is designed to do something slightly different, and choosing the right one depends on what your feet need.

This guide explains the differences in plain language, compares how they work, and helps you decide which is right for you.

The main types at a glance

Type What it is Main purpose
Cushioned insole A soft foam or gel layer Comfort and cushioning
Arch support An insert with a raised arch shape Basic, generic arch support
Prefabricated orthotic A firmer, pre-shaped orthotic in standard sizes Support and some motion control for an average foot
Custom orthotic An orthotic made from a model of your own feet Support and pressure distribution shaped to you

Cushioned insoles

Cushioned insoles are soft layers of foam or gel that replace or sit on top of your shoe's original insole. They feel comfortable and can soften impact, but they offer little structural support. They don't do much to hold up the arch or change how your foot moves, and soft materials tend to flatten over time.

Best for: people with no specific foot problems who want a little extra comfort.

Arch supports

Arch supports are inserts with a raised area under the arch. They're usually sold in standard sizes and shapes, sometimes with a few arch heights to choose from. They can provide basic support and may help mild tiredness or discomfort. The limitation is that the arch shape is generic: it may sit too far forward or back, or be too high or too low for your foot.

Best for: mild arch discomfort, or people trying support for the first time.

Prefabricated orthotics

Prefabricated orthotics are a step up. They're made from firmer materials, often with a defined heel cup and more structured arch support, and are designed to provide some control over how the foot moves. They're still made for an average foot in standard sizes, so the fit varies from person to person.

Best for: people who want more structure than a basic arch support and whose feet are close to average in shape.

Custom orthotics

Custom orthotics are made from a model of your own feet. That means the arch support, heel cup, and overall shape follow the contours of your foot, rather than an average one. They're typically made from durable materials designed for daily wear and can be designed for specific shoes and activities.

Best for: ongoing foot pain, flat feet or high arches, overpronation, people whose feet differ from each other, people on their feet all day, and anyone whose store-bought supports haven't helped. For a deeper comparison, see custom-made orthotics vs. over-the-counter insoles.

Key differences explained

Fit

Insoles and arch supports come in standard shapes. Custom orthotics are shaped to your feet, which is the single biggest difference.

Support

Cushioned insoles mainly cushion. Arch supports and prefabricated orthotics add generic support. Custom orthotics support your foot where it needs it.

Durability

Soft insoles and many arch supports flatten within months. Firmer orthotics, especially custom ones, are designed to keep their shape with daily use.

Cost

Insoles and arch supports are the cheapest upfront. Custom orthotics cost more, but they tend to last longer and are built for your feet. Fits Perfect custom orthotics are $249 with free shipping, and you may be eligible for HSA or FSA reimbursement, so check with your plan provider. See how much do custom orthotics cost?

Common myths

  • "Softer is always better." Soft cushioning feels nice at first, but it doesn't support your arch, and it compresses quickly.
  • "Any arch support will do." An arch in the wrong place can feel uncomfortable or do little to help.
  • "Orthotics are only for people with serious foot problems." Many people use them for everyday comfort, long workdays, and sport.
  • "You need a clinic visit for custom orthotics." You can now order them from home with a 3D foot scan.

How to choose

  • No pain, just want comfort? A cushioned insole or supportive shoe may be enough.
  • Mild arch tiredness? A basic arch support is a reasonable place to start.
  • Ongoing pain or a specific problem, like plantar fasciitis, flat feet, or overpronation? Custom orthotics are usually the better choice.
  • Tried several store-bought options without success? That's a strong sign your feet need support shaped to them.
  • On your feet all day for work or training? Durable, custom support tends to pay off.

If you're still unsure, read can I benefit from custom orthotic insoles? for a quick self-check.

Getting custom orthotics

With Fits Perfect, you scan your feet with your iPhone in the Fits Perfect app, a fast, simple, and accurate 3D scan. If you don't have an iPhone, a mail-in foam impression box is available. Choose a style for the shoes you wear most, such as Maximum Comfort for everyday shoes. Browse all custom orthotics.

When to see a podiatrist

If you have severe or sudden pain, swelling, numbness, diabetes, or pain after an injury, see a podiatrist or doctor before choosing any insole or orthotic.

Frequently asked questions

Are arch supports the same as orthotics?

Not quite. Arch supports provide generic support, while orthotics, especially custom ones, are more structured and can be shaped to your feet.

Are insoles and orthotics the same thing?

No. Insoles mainly cushion; orthotics are designed to support the foot's structure.

Do I need orthotics or just arch support?

Arch support may be enough for mild discomfort. Ongoing pain or specific foot problems usually call for orthotics.

Why are custom orthotics more expensive?

They're made from a model of your own feet using durable materials, rather than mass-produced in standard sizes.

Browse Custom Orthotics

Fits Perfect delivers professional-grade orthotics straight to your door.

No appointments. No prescriptions. No hassle.

Shop Orthotics

Cart

Close

Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping

Select options

Close
OR

Ordering With
3D Scan?

Checkout on the iPhone app

3D scan with iPhone

Ordering With
Impression Kit?

Checkout here
(NOTE: 1 kit per order)

Foam foot impression box